This was definitely the island dive bar experience I've been taking about. Up until this point I want sure I was going to find one. It's open air on the corner. 100% for the birds ha ha.
The drinks were cold. The pizza was okay. The bathrooms were crazy enough that they are definitely going to be told in stories for the rest of my life. Keep the expectations low and the chill vibes high.
Combination pizza was fantastic! Orgasmo drink, wonderful! Beef empanadas, fresh and melted in your mouth! We sat on the porch and watched the cars go by. Excellent!
It was AMAZING 💯🇵🇷❣️🙏🏽made us feel at home. Food OUTSTANDING👏🏾true island flavor. Unbelievable PIZZA 🍕 we have NOT had better😎. God’s grace we will return.Ate all three meals on one day or another😎 at Pizza City!
Dining at Pizza City was a frustrating experience from start to finish. The language barrier made it hard to communicate clearly with the staff, which led to some confusion when ordering. While I understand that language differences can happen, it would have helped if there were more effort to bridge that gap to improve the overall experience.
The food was really greasy, which made it feel heavy and unappetizing. The steak was especially disappointing—it wasn’t a proper cut of meat but rather pressed-down beef, almost like a minced meat patty. It lacked the texture and flavor you’d expect from a steak. The excess grease only made the dish feel more uncomfortable and less enjoyable.
To top it off, after finishing my meal, it took forever for anyone to come over to take my payment. Waiting around to pay when the restaurant wasn’t busy felt unnecessary and frustrating.
Final Thoughts: The combination of greasy food, poor food quality, language challenges, and slow service makes it hard to recommend Pizza City. Unless they address these issues, it's a place I wouldn't return to anytime soon.
Add Review
Read More Reviews
Chip Raines
a month agoThis was definitely the island dive bar experience I've been taking about. Up until this point I want sure I was going to find one. It's open air on the corner. 100% for the birds ha ha. The drinks were cold. The pizza was okay. The bathrooms were crazy enough that they are definitely going to be told in stories for the rest of my life. Keep the expectations low and the chill vibes high.
Janique Molborn
2 months agoCombination pizza was fantastic! Orgasmo drink, wonderful! Beef empanadas, fresh and melted in your mouth! We sat on the porch and watched the cars go by. Excellent!
Martha Diaz
3 months agoIt was AMAZING 💯🇵🇷❣️🙏🏽made us feel at home. Food OUTSTANDING👏🏾true island flavor. Unbelievable PIZZA 🍕 we have NOT had better😎. God’s grace we will return.Ate all three meals on one day or another😎 at Pizza City!
Nicholas Persaud
6 months agoDining at Pizza City was a frustrating experience from start to finish. The language barrier made it hard to communicate clearly with the staff, which led to some confusion when ordering. While I understand that language differences can happen, it would have helped if there were more effort to bridge that gap to improve the overall experience. The food was really greasy, which made it feel heavy and unappetizing. The steak was especially disappointing—it wasn’t a proper cut of meat but rather pressed-down beef, almost like a minced meat patty. It lacked the texture and flavor you’d expect from a steak. The excess grease only made the dish feel more uncomfortable and less enjoyable. To top it off, after finishing my meal, it took forever for anyone to come over to take my payment. Waiting around to pay when the restaurant wasn’t busy felt unnecessary and frustrating. Final Thoughts: The combination of greasy food, poor food quality, language challenges, and slow service makes it hard to recommend Pizza City. Unless they address these issues, it's a place I wouldn't return to anytime soon.
Bilguun Otgon-Ulzii
a week agoThe food was amazing. Would highly recommend