Marmalade

We were on our honeymoon and decided to splurge. So glad we did! Best meal of my life! First off the service was impeccable. They truly made you feel like a king. They knew it was a honeymoon dinner and brought us champagne and even a signed poster at the end with well wishes on it! The head chef and owner tries to make his rounds and talk to every table and tell you a little bit about the food. We did the tasting menu with the wine pairing. My favorite course was the famous white bean soup. My least favorite was the lamb meatballs, but they were still good. Every course was extremely flavorful and the perfect amount of food and wine. Worth every cent.

Every bite was immaculate and surprising. At one moment, I felt transported to a quiet street in Italy with handmade pasta so delicate and flavorful it could’ve come from a local Tuscan kitchen. The next, I was reminded of home in Maine—seafood so fresh it tasted as though it had just come off the boat. Marmalade offers a luxurious experience without being overdone; the service was warm, attentive, and perfectly elevated. My husband and I ordered completely different courses and were equally impressed with each dish from start to finish. Every plate was thoughtful, beautifully presented, and full of depth. As a special touch for our honeymoon, they decorated our table with rose petals and made us feel like royalty. Meeting the chef at the end of the evening was the perfect finale—he was gracious, passionate, and genuinely kind. This is a restaurant that knows how to craft a memorable experience.

Probably the best dining experience my wife and I have ever had. From the start, the staff was welcoming and accommodating. Ensuring we were comfortable where we were seated. They also made sure to ask about dietary restrictions and allergies which I appreciated as I have a shellfish allergy. All 5 courses were absolutely delicious. Every staff member was on the same page with one another, picking up where the last one left off. Since it was our anniversary the staff all signed a card and gave it to us, making it an even more special experience for us. This restaurant is well worth the price. Don’t hesitate to go here, just do it!!!

I booked Marmalade for an anniversary dinner with my wife while on vacation in Puerto Rico. The reviews and pictures looked enticing, and the menu looked great. Let me tell you, Marmalade did NOT disappoint! The restaurant is decorated beautifully, giving it an amazing ambiance and vibe. We were warmly greeted and seated in a corner table that was low with tons of pillows on a large couch thing, allowing my wife and I to sit next to each other. It turned out to be quite comfy and also really romantic. The service was friendly and impeccable. They only do a tasting menu, but you get several choices per course, so there’s something for everyone. I will say that everything we had was absolutely delicious, and beautifully presented. The highlight was the malanga gnocchi with short rib. It was one of the best things I’ve ever eaten in my life, honestly. At the end the head chef came out to talk to us, he was very friendly and down to earth. Is it a little pricey? Yes. But trust me, it is money well spent and worth every single penny. Seriously one of the best meals I’ve ever had, and I’ve eaten all over the world, from Napa to London to Barcelona. Marmalade stands with the best of the best. I’m shocked they don’t have a Michelin Star yet.

Santi was our server and he was amazing, we did the wine pairing and he explained each of the wines and how to enjoy them with the meal perfectly. He was very kind, he gave us time to look through the menu and gave us recommendations. I had several favorites like The Three Pigs, Lobster Risotto, the White Bean Soup & the popcorn shrimp.